Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Cataloging the Carnegie


 
Pterodactyloid specimen with the impression of a throat pouch preserved
The number of pterosaur specimens now known from the Solnhofen is very impressive, certainly in the hundreds, although with a good number sitting in private hands, plenty of information is kinda known about, without necessarily being in the literature. However, while it is easy to bemoan the inaccessibility of material that isn’t in museums, far too much that is available is not always looked at, and a great case in point is the collection of Solnhofen material in the Carnegie Museum in Pittsburgh. In the early 1900s, the Carnegie was able to acquire a large collection of fossils from a Belgian collector the Baron de Bayet, and this included considerable amounts of Solnhofen fossils including a dozen pterosaurs. This is arguably the best collection outside of Europe, or even outside or Germany, and includes material in 3D, with soft tissues, stomach contents and other rather nice details. However, in the following hundred years a total of just 10 papers even mention these specimens, and some of these are very much references in passing. The only even vaguely detailed mentions come from Peter Wellnhofer’s works from the 1970s, which are not easy to access these days, often available only with poor images, don’t illustrate all the specimens, and came in many cases prior to additional preparation or other modifications. In short, this is a major collection of pterosaurs which needs to be revisited.

While visiting Mike Habib in Pittsburgh, we were hunting for things to do and realised this was an area ripe for reappraisal and set to revising and updating the material. Joining forces with Carnegie curator Matt Lamanna, we have now published a long paper (appropriately enough in the Annals of Carnegie Museum) detailing the material and its history. Naturally we have not done detailed descriptions of the anatomy of the pterosaurs at hand – there are very good descriptions of  things like Rhamphorhynchus and adding to that would merely fill space without really conveying much useful information, so instead we focused on what is unique about each specimen (taphonomy, condition of the material, what is and isn’t present) and specific history of the material in places. For completeness, we even briefly covered the casts in the collection, and the skeletal models made by Wellnhofer when he was in the museum on a sabbatical many years ago. This still resulted in a manuscript of over 15 000 words (despite there being only a handful of references) and 15 figures (at least one of each specimen), while Mike rather heroically took dozens of measurements for each specimen and then repeated the exercise for accuracy. The paper is in black and white, but colour versions of the key figures are online here alongside the data.

Some of these specimens turned out to be much more interesting and potentially important than previously realised and we were also able to correct some previous problems and update the taxonomy. Recent revisions especially to the pterodactyloids has left a lot of collections lagging in their taxonomy, but there was also a large animal that was listed as Rhamphorhynchus, despite obviously being a pterodactyloid, and indeed actually doesn’t even bear much resemblance to any currently known Solnhofen pterosaur and is rather cryptic. Two specimens had been mistakenly thought to be a plate and counterplate and had been combined even though they were quite different. After much head scratching we realised the issue was that there was a plate and counterplate there, but thanks to effectively a typo, the wrong pair had been put together.

Rhamphorhynchus specimen prepared free of the matrix

Two specimens of Rhamphorhynchus have undergone pretty dramatic changes in recent years, having been fully prepared free of their matrix. In one case, this results in a very odd flat specimen (which is apparently now very fragile – I actually didn’t see either of these, they were away when I was at the Carnegie) but that is at least cleaned up, but the other is a near complete skull preserved in 3D. Many readers will remember the paper on pterosaur neuroanatomy led by Larry Witmer that compared the brain structures of Anhanguera and Rhamphorhynchus and this specimen was responsible for the data on the latter. Three dimensional material from the Solnhofen is not common, so a skull that is in 3D and prepared to the point that it can be seen in all views is a real treasure and while it has been scanned, we’ve included a series of large photos of it to help reveal the structure.

 
Rhamphorhynchus skull in near 3D (if lacking teeth) prepared free of the matrix

Several specimens show traces of soft tissues including the wings, throat sacs and tail vanes. None are especially well preserved, but nor ore these features that common either (in part perhaps because like the leg feathers of Archaeopteryx, they may have been destroyed in the past to ‘better’ prepare specimens), so any additional information is useful. Finally, one of them does appear to have some fish teeth associated with the stomach. We this is has been missed before by other people and so is a novel find, and that extends the set of Rhamphorhynchus specimens with fish gut contents and firms up the evidence for piscivory as a major part of the diet of these animals.

Hopefully therefore this paper will clarify a few issues with the collection, bring forwards some of the developments and details not previously seen or recognised and provides a basis for future research. Also of course it marks the beginning of the sad death of Matt Lamanna’s career as a researcher of dinosaurs and the slow and painful descent into working on pterosaurs and consorting with the kinds of people who actually quite like them. For this Mike and I can only apologise, or cackle wildly with unabandonned joy, depending on who is reading at the time.

Hone, D.W.E., Habib, M.B. & Lamanna, M.C. 2013. An annotated and illustrated catalogue of Solnhofen (Upper Jurassic, Germany) pterosaur specimens at Carnegie Museum of Natural History. Annals of Carnegie Museum, 82: 165-191.Link to PDF here.

23 comments:

  1. Situs POKER paling menarik....
    Apalagi kalau bukan RUBYQQ
    Dengan didukung server terbaik.

    Keunggulan Bermain Bersama kami :
    - 100% Fair Play ( Player vs Player )
    - Bisa bermain dengan Versi ANDRIOD & IPHONE
    - Minimal Deposit 15.000,- Withdraw 15.000,-
    - Support Bank BCA - BNI - BRI - CIMB - Mandiri.

    Untuk informasi lebih lengkap silahkan Hubungi Customer Service kami :
    *BBM : 2B8938F7
    *FACEBOOK : rubyqq
    *SKYPE : RUBY QQ
    *Livechat 24 jam : Official site rubyqq

    ReplyDelete
  2. Silahkan di kunjungi ya kawan-kawan 100% Memuaskan
    > Hoki anda ada di sini <
    Allsbobet 1 DOMPET DEPOSITO Untuk Semua Permainan !!
    WELCOME BONUS 100%
    SPORTSBOOK CASINO TOGEL POKER E E-GAMES SLOT MACHINE NUMBER GAME SABUNG AYAM TEMBAK IKAN DAN SEBAGAINYA

    Tentunya dengan berbagai BONUS-BONUS:
    - Minimal Deposit Rp 50.000 & Withdraw Rp 50.000
    - BONUS NEW MEMBER SPORTBOOK 100%
    - BONUS ALL GAME 10%
    - BONUS ROLLINGAN LIVE CASINO 0.8%
    - BONUS REFFERAL 2.5%

    Gabung yuk bersama dengan kami di ALLSBOBET.COM
    Terpercaya Sejak 2015 - MENANG BERAPAPUN KAMI BAYAR
    Proses Deposit / Withdraw gak pake ribet, proses CEPAT !!

    UNTUK INFORMASI SELANJUTNYA BISA HUB KAMI DI :
    LIVECHAT ALLSBOBET.COM 24 JAM ONLINE : https://lc.chat/now/8533171/
    Pin BBM : D60E1BF8
    LINE : ALLSBOBET
    WECHAT : ALLSBOBET
    WHATSAPP : +855 974 832 357

    Agen Togel
    Agen Bola
    Agen Kasino
    Togel SGP
    Togel Hongkong
    Togel Sydney
    Judi Online
    Agen Judi
    Agen Judi QQ
    Forum Judi Online

    hubungi kami di :
    Line : ALLSBOBET
    Bbm : D60E1BF8
    Wa : +855974832357

    ReplyDelete
  3. Cari poker aman dan terpercaya ? Buruan gabung bersama Menteripoker agen poker dan domino terbaik dan terpercaya.
    Minimal deposit hanya Rp 15.000 saja dan disupport 10 bank ternama di Indonesia.
    Bonus turnover 0,5% dibagikan setiap hari kamis.
    Bonus mingguan berupa Sepeda motor yamaha, Handphone, Uang tunai, Chip, Notepad.
    Info lebih lanjut CS 24/7 ( BBM : D60CE855 ) ( LINE:menteripoker )

    ReplyDelete
  4. Silahkan di kunjungi ya kawan-kawan 100% Memuaskan
    > Hoki anda ada di sini <
    1 USER ID UNTUK SEMUA GAME
    Kami memberi bukti bukan Janji
    Daftar sekarang juga dan dapatkan bonus menarik dari kami :
    - BONUS DEPOSIT NEW MEMBER 100%
    - BONUS DEPOSIT HARIAN 5.000 - 20.000
    - BONUS REFFERAL 2%
    MIN DEPO & WD HANYA Rp.50.000,-
    BCA - MANDIRI - BRI - BNI - DANAMON
    UNTUK INFORMASI SELANJUTNYA BISA HUB KAMI DI :
    LIVECHAT TOGEL118.COM 24 JAM ONLINE
    Pin BBM : D8AF7278
    LINE : togel118
    WHATSAPP : +855 92985834
    Prediksi">http://prediksibwin.com/">Prediksi Bola
    Cerita">http://ceritasemi.com/">Cerita Dewasa
    Cerita">http://ceritasemi.com/">Cerita Semi
    Cerita">http://ayocoli.com/">Cerita Sex
    Prediksi">http://newsprediksi.com/">Prediksi Togel
    Judi Online
    Agen Bola

    ReplyDelete
  5. ♥♠♣♦ Selamat Datang di KipasQQ ♥♠♣♦
    Ayo segera bergabung bersama kami di kipasqq
    ------------------------------------------------------------------
    AGEN POKER ONLINE TERBAIK DAN TERPERCAYA
    Rasakan sensasi bermain di website kami dengan minimal deposit Rp.10.000 Dan withdraw Rp 20.000
    mainkan 8 games hanya dalam 1 user ID :
    > ADUQ
    > POKER
    > BANDARPOKER
    > BANDARQ
    > CAPSASUSUN
    > DOMINO99
    > SAKONG
    > BANDAR66
    -------------------------------------------------------------------
    Dan dapatkan juga berbagai bonus yang kami berikan :
    > Bonus cashback 0,3% - 0,5 % (Dibagikan setiap hari senin)
    > Bonus refferensi 20%
    > LiveChat 24 jam
    > Proses depo wd tercepat
    > No Robot.
    > 100% Player VS Player
    > Proses Deposit dan Withdraw Tercepat.
    > 24 jam pelayanan Costumer Service yang ramah.
    > Support bank BCA, MANDIRI, BNI, BRI, DANAMON
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------
    Untuk Info Lebih Lanjut Silahkan Hub Cs Kami
    Contact Us :
    BBM : 7ABFA6AB
    Yahoo Mesg : memberkipasqq
    LINE : KIPASQQ
    Whatsapp : +85515 864 136
    Wechat : KIPASQQ
    Segera daftarkan user id anda sekarang juga hanya di kipasqq
    DAN JADILAH PEMENANGNYA !!
    ♣♠♥♦KIPASQQ♣♠♥♦

    ReplyDelete
  6. really liked this article because it gives a lot of inspiration thanks. please visit my website Daftar Situs Poker

    Online

    ReplyDelete
  7. Siapkan diri anda untuk kemenangan yang berlimpah di SahabatQQ

    Hanya dengan modal minimal deposit 20.000 dapat membuat anda menjadi jutawan loh ^^
    Dengan 8 jenis game yang seru dan sangat mudah di mainkan

    Apalagi yang kalian nantikan , mari join di SahabatQQ
    Link alternatif :

    - sahabat9988,net
    - Duniasakong,com
    - Duniasakong,net
    - Duniasakong,org
    - Duniasakong,info

    ReplyDelete
  8. Situs Taruhan Sabung Ayam AgenS128 di support provider S128 dan juga bisa dimainkan di smartphone

    SABUNG AYAM LIVE STREAMING, saksikan secara langsung dan pasang taruhan Anda.

    Segera bergabung dengan kami di AGENS128 dan raih bonusmu sekarang juga!!

    BONUS BESAR KLIK DISINI
    SABUNG AYAM INDONESIA
    SABUNG AYAM TERBESAR
    SABUNG AYAM TERBAIK
    PROMO BONUS SABUNG AYAM
    JUDI TARUHAN AYAM
    AGEN JUDI TARUHAN BESAR
    SABUNG AYAM S128


    Untuk info selanjutnya, bisa hubungi kami di:
    WEBSITE : https://www.linktr.ee/s128agen
    BBM : D8B84EE1 / AGENS128
    WA : 0852-2255-5128

    Terima kasih .. Salam Agens128 :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. TT4D | TOGEL TERPERCAYA | AGEN TOGEL ONLINE TERPERCAYA

    Dengan Fiture-fiture Terbaik sebagai berikut :
    • Hadiah Prize 4D dan 3D Semua Pasaran
    • BBFS 10 Digit Tanpa Batasan Line
    • Bonus Referral Sebesar 0,5% dari Semua Pemasangan Seumur Hidup
    • Tersedia Live Games dan Sbobet Bola atau Casino

    Hadiah & Diskon TT4D :
    • HADIAH 4D x 3.000 ( 65% )
    • HADIAH 3D x 400 ( 59% )
    • HADIAH 2D x 70 ( 29% )

    Hadiah Hiburan Jackpot 4D & 3D Semua Pasaran :
    Prize I : x 3 Juta ( 4D ) | x 400 Ribu ( 3D )
    Prize II : 200 Ribu ( 4D ) | 20 Ribu ( 3D )
    Prize III : 100 Ribu ( 4D ) | 10 Ribu ( 3D )
    Started Prize : 55 Ribu ( Hanya 4D )
    Consolation : 25 Ribu ( Hanya 4D )

    Pasaran TT4D Togel Terpercaya :
    • Vietnam Tutup Jam 11.00 WIB dan Result Jam 11.30 WIB
    • Sydney Tutup Jam 13.30 WIB dan Result Jam 13.50 WIB
    • Las Vegas Tutup Jam 15.30 WIB dan Result Jam 16.00 WIB
    • Singapore Tutup Jam 17.25 WIB dan Result Jam 17.45 WIB
    • Lemacau Tutup Jam 19.30 WIB dan Result Jam 20.00 WIB
    • Hongkong Tutup Jam 22.30 WIB dan Result Jam 23.00 WIB

    Website Login / Daftar :
    DAFTAR TT4D

    Kontak Official :
    - Pin BBM : TT4DOK
    - WA : +855963240368

    ReplyDelete
  10. Haiii Bagi Yang Ingin Bermain Judi Online Terpercaya Se Asia Ayoo Segera Bergabung Bersama Kami Di TexasPokerQQ

    Promo-Promo Yang Kami Sediakan.
    * BONUS NEW MEMBER 20%
    * BONUS NEXT DEPOSIT SEBESAR 5%
    * BONUS TURN OVER 1%
    * BONUS REFERRAL 10%+10% plus+10%=30%
    Game Yang Tersedia Adalah Sebagai Berikut.
    * POKER
    * CEME KELILING / BANDAR Q KELILING
    * CEME / BANDAR Q
    * CAPSA SUSUN / BIG TWO / 13 KARTU
    * DOMINO QQ
    * SUPER TEN / THREE PICTURES / SAMGONG
    * POKER OMAHA
    Dan di suport oleh 6 bank terbaik di Indonesia yaitu.
    1. BCA
    2. BNI
    3. BRI
    4. MANDIRI
    5. DANAMON
    6. CIMB NIAGA
    Kelebihan bermain di Texaspokerqq dengan agen-agen lain adalah.
    1. Deposit Minimal hanya Rp 10.000 dan Withdraw Minimal 30.000 saja dan prosesnya sangat cepat.
    2. Fairplay 100% Murni player vs player.
    3. Pelayanan 24 Jam terbaik buat customer.
    4. Bisa di proses melalui 6 bank terbaik di indonesia.

    Untuk info lebih lanjut, silahkan hubungi kami di.
    Website : www.Texasceme.com
    PIN BBM : 335A3785
    WHATSAPP : +6281260135206
    SKYPE : Texas PokerQQ
    TWITTER : @TexasPokerQQ
    LINE : chenxiaooo
    FaceBook : @Chenxiao Mei

    ReplyDelete
  11. Cari Situs Judi Online Terpercaya? Teraman? Banyak Bonusnya?
    Di Sini Tempatnya.

    ZumaQQ.com Agen Bandarq Domino 99 Bandar Poker Online Terpercaya

    Hanya 4 Tahapan Kemenangan yang MUDAH di ZumaQQ
    Daftar > Depo > Main > Menang!
    Deposit minimal Rp. 20.000,-
    Anda Bisa Menjadi JUTAWAN? Kenapa Tidak?
    Dengan 1 ID sudah bisa bermain 8 Jenis Permainan
    * BandarQ (HOT)
    * Bandar 66 (New Hot)
    * Bandar Poker
    * Sakong Online
    * Domino QQ
    * Adu Q
    * Poker
    * Capsa Susun
    Ada Juga Bonus Terhot Se-Indonesia
    Bonus Turnover 0,5%
    Bonus Refferal 10% + 10%
    Bonus Extra Refferal 5%

    - Promo Extra Turnover yang dibagikan setiap tanggal 01 dan tanggal 16 Setiap bulannya dengan minimal Turnover sebagai berikut :

    * Turn Over 10 jt = FreeChips Rp 25.000 ,-
    * Turn Over 25 jt = FreeChips Rp 50.000 ,-
    * Turn Over 50 jt = FreeChips Rp 100.000,-
    * Turn Over 100 jt = FreeChips Rp 250.000,-
    * Turn Over 200 jt = FreeChips Rp 500.000,-

    Yuk gabung bersama kami dan Jadilah Jutawan Berikutnya!
    Website : ZumaQQ
    BBM : ZumaQQ
    WA : +6281218571961
    Line : ZumaQQ
    Facebook 1 : Facebook
    Twitter : Twitter
    Blog 1 : Cerita Dewasa
    Blog 2 : ZumaQQ
    Blog 3 : indozuma
    Blog 4 : IDZUMAQQ

    ReplyDelete
  12. MandiriCasino - Situs Judi Casino Online Terbesar & Terpercaya Serta Membuat Anda Nyaman Bermain dan Pastinya ada Promo - Promo Menarik Bagi Anda Juga dan Jangan Sampai Ketinggalan.

    MandiriCasino merupakan Situs Judi Casino Online yang Terbesar & Terpercaya Dengan Deposit Termurah Hanya 20.000,- saja Sudah Bisa Bermain Game Yang Telah Disediakan dan Pastinya Membuat Para Membernya Merasa Nyaman dan Aman Saat Bermain di Situs Kami dan Sudah Tentu Untuk Para Bettor di Seluruh Indonesia Untuk Mendapatkan Keuntungan Lebih.


    Nikmati Promo - Promo Yang Disediakan MandiriCasino :

    * Bonus Rollingan Casino 1%

    * Bonus Cashback 2%

    * Bonus Referral 3% Seumur Hidup



    Kunjungi Website MandiriCasino :

    http://mandiricasino.net/index.jsp

    BBM :E339A310

    WhatsApp :+6285280375817

    ReplyDelete
  13. ituDewa.com Poker Domino QQ | Ceme Judi Domino QQ | Agen Domino QQ | Domino QQ Online | Agen Poker | Judi Poker | Poker Online | Agen BlackJack |

    Agen Judi Online Terpercaya dan Terbaik di Indonesia
    Menyediakan berbagai macam permainan Judi Kartu Online Terlengkap

    1 ID untuk 7 Game Permainan yang disediakan oleh Situs ituDewa

    * DominoQQ
    * Poker
    * Bandar Ceme
    * Capsa Susun
    * Super 10
    * Ceme Keliling
    * Omaha Poker


    => Bonus Cashback 0.3% (dibagikan setiap hari kamis)
    => Bonus Refferal 20% (dibagikan setiap Minggunya seumur hidup)
    => Customer Service 24 Jam Nonstop
    => Support 7 Bank Lokal Indonesia (BCA, BNI, BRI, Mandiri, Danamon, Cimb Niaga, Permata Bank)

    * Pusat Bantuan ituDewa

    LINE : ituDewa
    WECHAT : OfficialituDewa
    WHATSAPP : +85511251182

    Kunjungi Juga Situs Bola & Casino Online Terlengkap :

    ituBola - Judi Bola - Judi Casino - Judi Poker - Judi Domino QQ
    * ituCasino - Judi Casino - Judi Bola - Judi Poker - Judi Domino QQ

    ReplyDelete