Monday, November 12, 2012
Pterosaur fact checking
I will keep this brief, since Mark already did a great job of responding to the media release from the recent Chatterjee et al. presentation. One thing to look for in any sort of functional morphology argument is whether the anatomy, the numbers, and the behavior all match up. One reason the Chatterjee et al. abstract is so immediately concerning is that their own information doesn't jive internally.
Example 1: one of their concerns with the quad launch hypothesis is clearance for the wings after launch. Now, I've calculated the expected clearance and everything seems fine, but that doesn't mean I'm right. Maybe someone will find an error at some point. What is clearly not going to be true, however, is the idea that keeping the feet on the ground (biped running launch) is going to give more clearance than a leap. It simply isn't possible to get more clearance by not jumping (it might be true that jumping still isn't enough, but it's not going to be worse). So Chatterjee et al. have a mismatch between their own conclusions and their arguments with the competing model. The numbers and the behavior don't match up.
Example 2: Chatterjee et al. argue that pterosaurs can't work as scaled up bats, and argue instead that they should work like scaled up birds. Anatomically, pterosaurs don't match either of these, so the bat argument is a straw man, and the bird argument is moot. The anatomy and the behavior don't match up.
These are the sorts of arguments that raise red flags in scientific discourse. On a final note, there are some basic fact checking items that should be looked out for, such as claims about living animals. From the media story, Chatterjee is quoted as saying "Like albatrosses and the Great Kori bustards, which weigh 20 to 40 pounds, ground takeoff was agonizing and embarrassing for Quetzalcoatlus."
Aside from the problem with the pterosaur analogy, there is the obvious problem that Kori bustards don't have trouble taking off (though they might find it embarrassing; I haven't asked them). In fact, Kori bustards can leap into flight at a steep angle. Check this out. Yes, the bustard tries running to escape, first, but when pressed, it just leaps into the air. No big runway, no "agonizing" takeoff. In fact, there is no correlation between running launch and size in living birds or bats. More on that some other time, but in general, if a YouTube search quickly demonstrates that your commentary is flawed, that's a bit worrisome.
Example 1: one of their concerns with the quad launch hypothesis is clearance for the wings after launch. Now, I've calculated the expected clearance and everything seems fine, but that doesn't mean I'm right. Maybe someone will find an error at some point. What is clearly not going to be true, however, is the idea that keeping the feet on the ground (biped running launch) is going to give more clearance than a leap. It simply isn't possible to get more clearance by not jumping (it might be true that jumping still isn't enough, but it's not going to be worse). So Chatterjee et al. have a mismatch between their own conclusions and their arguments with the competing model. The numbers and the behavior don't match up.
Example 2: Chatterjee et al. argue that pterosaurs can't work as scaled up bats, and argue instead that they should work like scaled up birds. Anatomically, pterosaurs don't match either of these, so the bat argument is a straw man, and the bird argument is moot. The anatomy and the behavior don't match up.
These are the sorts of arguments that raise red flags in scientific discourse. On a final note, there are some basic fact checking items that should be looked out for, such as claims about living animals. From the media story, Chatterjee is quoted as saying "Like albatrosses and the Great Kori bustards, which weigh 20 to 40 pounds, ground takeoff was agonizing and embarrassing for Quetzalcoatlus."
Aside from the problem with the pterosaur analogy, there is the obvious problem that Kori bustards don't have trouble taking off (though they might find it embarrassing; I haven't asked them). In fact, Kori bustards can leap into flight at a steep angle. Check this out. Yes, the bustard tries running to escape, first, but when pressed, it just leaps into the air. No big runway, no "agonizing" takeoff. In fact, there is no correlation between running launch and size in living birds or bats. More on that some other time, but in general, if a YouTube search quickly demonstrates that your commentary is flawed, that's a bit worrisome.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Come now Mike, who are you going to believe, the press or your lying eyes?
ReplyDeleteI was going to roll dice, in fact.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the interesting comment. Reading the media, it seems that their model of take off for Albatross or Quetzalcoatlus is based on Orville or Wilbur form the Disney Bernard and Bianca ;-)).
ReplyDeleteon a related, is there books or article accessible to non specialist about mechanism of flight or take off, ’ find always fascinating when you brought to us element as the near vertical take of of gallinacean.
Alexandre
David Alexander's book on animal flight is relatively accessible, though it doesn't talk much about takeoff (perhaps not coincidentally, he is part of the "et al." in the Chatterjee et al. presentation on Quetzalcoatlus launch; perhaps takeoff isn't something he's worked on much). There are very general books/papers on takeoff, specifically, I am afraid to say.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the answer. I'll check this book.
ReplyDeleteAlexandre
Agen Judi Online
ReplyDeleteAgen Judi Sbobet
Agen Judi Ibcbet
Agen Judi Casino Online
Agen Judi Tangkas
Prediksi Bola Akurat
Berita Bola
Harian Bola
Seputar Sepakbola
I can’t imagine the world without you. I only know it would be a much different, much less comforting place.
ReplyDeletebandar togel online
promo togel
daftar togel
main togel
Very Nice And Interesting Post, thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteShort Inspirational Quotes - Gym Quotes
Best Quotes - Future Quotes - xyore
Image Bank - Positive Life Quotes
Success Quotes - حكمة اليوم
كلام جميل - حكم عن الحياة
J P S P O K E R adalah situs judi online dan agen judi online terpercaya yang di layanin oleh CS yang sangat ramah dan cepat dalam memproses Depo dan WD member J P S P O K E R dan di J P S P O K E R tersedia permainan Poker Judi Online Seperti Berikut : (Poker, Capsa, DominoQQ, Ceme, Super Teen, Ceme Keliling, Omaha) dan dapatkan promo dari JPSPOKER sebagai berikut:
ReplyDelete- Bonus New Member Rp. 10.000
- Minimal Deposit / Withdraw Rp. 15,000.-
- Bonus Refferal 10%
- Bonus Rollingan Mingguan 0.3% - 0,5%
Baca Juga Di Tonton Video jav dan Video Semi kami :
jpspoker,me(pakai titik ya)
- Pelayanan Dari Customer Service Yang Cantik Tentunya Sopan Dan Ramah, Hanya di jpspoker dan , Online 24/7 Jam
- Dijamin Tidak Ada Robot Di Dalamnya 1000% Player VS Player
Kalau Ada Yang Bisa Berikan Lebih Kenapa Harus Cari Yang Lain!!
Contact Us
- Livechat : JPSPOKER.LIVE
- LINE : jpspoker
- Whatsapp : +82370836863
- YM : JPSPOKER
POKER UANG ASLI
POKER ONLINE TERBAIK
JUDI POKER INDONESIA
AGEN POKER TERBAIK
AGEN POKER TERPERCAYA
AGEN JUDI POKER
JPSPOKER
BANDAR CEME
GAME OMAHA
AGEN DOMINO
Kaliteli escort bayanlarla tanışma fırsatı yakalamak için tıkla: ankara escort ankara escort ankara escort izmir escort ankara escort ankara escort ankara escort ankara escort ankara escort
ReplyDeleteKaliteli escort bayanlarla tanışma fırsatı yakalamak için tıkla: ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort - ankara escort
ReplyDeleteİşinize yarayabilecek siteler listesi hemen aşağıda: binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - google haritalara yer ekleme - kuşadası kiralık villa - tiktok izlenme satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - sms onay - polen filtresi
ReplyDeleteinstagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - tiktok takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram beğeni satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - instagram beğeni satın al - instagram beğeni satın al - polen filtresi - google haritalara yer ekleme - btcturk güvenilir mi - binance hesap açma - kuşadası kiralık villa - tiktok izlenme satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - sms onay - paribu sahibi - binance sahibi - btcturk sahibi - paribu ne zaman kuruldu - binance ne zaman kuruldu - btcturk ne zaman kuruldu - youtube izlenme satın al - torrent oyun - google haritalara yer ekleme - altyapısız internet - bedava internet - no deposit bonus forex - erkek spor ayakkabı - webturkey.net - minecraft premium hesap - karfiltre.com - tiktok jeton hilesi - tiktok beğeni satın al - microsoft word indir - misli indir
ReplyDeleteadanaescort01.com - adiyamanescortxx.com - afyonarackiralama.net - aksarayescort.net - antalyaoyunpark.com - aydinescortkiz.com - balikesirescortlar.com - batmanescortlar.com - bitlisescortlar.com - burdurescortlar.com - bursamalaysias.com - diyarbakirambar.com - edirnedespor.com - erzurumyolkosusu.com - eskisehirescortlari.com - gaziantepekspres.org - gebzeescortkiz.com - giresunmaraton.com - hataykoleji.com - ispartakpss.com - karabukteknik.com - kastamonuajans.net - kayserivalisi.com - kilisescort.com - kocaeliescortlar.com - konyaescortlar.com - kutahyaizemlak.com - malatyadataksi.com - manisaescortlar.com - marasatasoyemlak.com - mardinfanatik.com - mersinmoda.com - muglaapart.net - nigdeyapi.com - orduescortt.com - osmaniyeyorum.com - sakaryanur.com - samsunescortlar.com - siirteyatirim.com - sincanoto.com - tekirdagescortlar.com - tokatforum.com - usakbasin.com - vanescortilan.com - yalovadaemlak.com - yozgattanal.com - sanliurfadayim.com - zonguldakescort.com
ReplyDeletekayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - kayseri escort - gaziantep escort
ReplyDeletekayseri escort - hatay escort
ReplyDeleteinstagram takipçi satın al
ReplyDeleteinstagram takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
instagram takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
instagram takipçi satın al
aşk kitapları
tiktok takipçi satın al
instagram beğeni satın al
youtube abone satın al
twitter takipçi satın al
tiktok beğeni satın al
tiktok izlenme satın al
twitter takipçi satın al
tiktok takipçi satın al
youtube abone satın al
tiktok beğeni satın al
instagram beğeni satın al
trend topic satın al
trend topic satın al
youtube abone satın al
beğeni satın al
tiktok izlenme satın al
sms onay
youtube izlenme satın al
tiktok beğeni satın al
sms onay
sms onay
perde modelleri
instagram takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
tiktok jeton hilesi
pubg uc satın al
sultanbet
marsbahis
betboo
betboo
betboo
instagram takipçi satın al
ReplyDeleteucuz takipçi
takipçi satın al
https://takipcikenti.com
https://ucsatinal.org
instagram takipçi satın al
https://perdemodelleri.org
https://yazanadam.com
instagram takipçi satın al
balon perdeler
petek üstü perde
mutfak tül modelleri
kısa perde modelleri
fon perde modelleri
tül perde modelleri
https://atakanmedya.com
https://fatihmedya.com
https://smmpaketleri.com
https://takipcialdim.com
https://yazanadam.com
yasaklı sitelere giriş
aşk kitapları
yabancı şarkılar
sigorta sorgula
https://cozumlec.com
word indir ücretsiz
tiktok jeton hilesi
rastgele görüntülü sohbet
erkek spor ayakkabı
fitness moves
gym workouts
https://marsbahiscasino.org
http://4mcafee.com
http://paydayloansonlineare.com
diyarbakır eskort
ReplyDeleteizmit eskort
bodrum eskort
urfa eskort
bitlis eskort
bingöl eskort
bursa eskort
erzurum eskort
erzincan eskort
samsun eskort
gümüşhane eskort
ReplyDeletebatman eskort
çorlu eskort
marmaris eskort
fethiye eskort
çeşme eskort
iskenderun eskort
ısparta eskort
kıbrıs eskort
kırklareli eskort
afyon eskort
ReplyDeleteağrı eskort
adana eskort
batman eskort
yozgat eskort
eskort bayan
düzce masöz
manisa masöz
izmit masöz
görükle masöz
malatya bayan
ReplyDeleteağrı bayan
adana bayan
kilis bayan
osmaniye bayan
siirt bayan
muş bayan
bartın bayan
sivas bayan
çorlu bayan
..hi Are you ready to hear something crazy? I love you, pal
ReplyDelete.I know, I cannot believe that too. But you make this world a better place, and I appreciate it very much
.I want you to know that I’m really grateful. دانلود آهنگ زانکو عشقم اینه