Thursday, January 2, 2014

Pterosaur Aerodynamics at GWU

+Lorena Barba over at George Washington University had her students do some fun summaries of pterosaur aerodynamics at the end of the Fall Semester. She is a professor in engineering who runs a course on animal flight (she is also the CFD guru behind the latest analysis of gliding snakes with J. Socha). These topics followed from a discussion that Lorena and I had after some interesting (and amusing) trolling on my Google+ stream. We identified four topics for her students to look into more: pterosaur launch, pterosaur weight estimates, pterosaur wings and flight capabilities, and Wagner Effects. The students wrote blog posts, which can be found here:

http://lorenabarba.com/blog/student-guest-blog-post-pterosaur-quad-launch/

http://lorenabarba.com/blog/student-guest-blog-post-pterosaur-weight-estimation/

http://lorenabarba.com/blog/student-guest-blog-post-pterosaur-wings-and-flight-capabilities/

http://lorenabarba.com/blog/student-guest-blog-post-the-wagner-effect/

These students are all engineers, which adds a fun element because most were quite unfamiliar with pterosaur biology going into this project. There are some errors in the terminology and details of biology as a result, but it's quite good work, and brought some new things to light for me (especially the Wagner section). Enjoy!

Oh, and Happy New Year everyone...


77 comments:

  1. Dear Lorena Barba,
    I enjoyed the guest blogs done by your students. Although the first three were based on the well-known Habib/Witton/Palmer canon, I was more interested in the blog on the Wagner effect.

    There were still a few howler however. In the Druv/Golding blog they state that "Tupuxuara weighs in at 22.8 kg, nearly half the weight of the largest flying modern birds at 41 kg."
    As far as I know, the heaviest modern flying bird is the Kori Bustard at 19Kg. I am not aware of any bird flying at 41Kg. Perhaps this is a typo for lbs rather than kg? If so, it should really have been checked before release.

    Another one was the delightfully simplistic 4th part of the quadrepedal launch sequence: I quote: "Launch —In the final phase, the pterosaur completed its quadrupedal launch and took off." This is phraseology straight out of a childrens' novel and not really scientific language at all.

    Finally, there was the maths that went awry on the blog on weight estimation (Forcha) where we appear to have mention of pterosaur wing loadings of 220Kg/m2. That is greater than a B-17 Bomber! I suspect this should have read 22Kg/m2. Another typo perhaps but they all detract from the credibility of the whole article.

    I have managed to get under the skin of several palaeontologists including Habib, Witton, Palmer et al. From my reading of learned articles, it would appear that the palaeontological community have become used to making statements about what these extinct creatures could and couldn't do.

    It is easy for palaeontologists to pontificate on the taxonomy of ground or even sea-dwelling creatures, with little fear of contradiction. Who can say how heavy a Tricerotops weighed or how fast a Plesiosaur could swim? However, when it comes to Pterosaurs, they are rigidly bound by the laws of aerodynamics. Habib has postulated that Quetzalcoatlus N. could fly at 80 mph; fly non-stop half way around the globe at 15,000 ft. And that ridiculous theory of the quad launch! His arguments are that some modern birds can do it so why can’t Quetzy. My counter argument is that Penguins, Hummingbirds and Gannets are also birds – does that mean that Quetzalcoatlus could swim, hover and dive? We need to get away from the theatrical postulations of recent years. Let’s try instead to work out whether and how these creatures lived and – if indeed they did - flew.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Come on Lorena Barba's team. What about some feedback?

    ReplyDelete
  3. OK No feedback? I am an aerodynamicist. If we are going to get the big, late-Cretaceous pterosaurs to fly we HAVE to have all their dimensions in order to fit in with aerodynamic theory. We have lengths, widths etc from fossils, but no-one can come up with a weight that matches. We must rely on palaeontologists to come up with a professional estimate for us. With Quetzalcoatlus we have been given a 30ft wingspan with (according to Mark Witton) a body only 60cm long. Yes, 60 cm. The height of a giraffe but weighing only 250Kg. This is the creature that Habib has flying at 15,000 ft and travelling at 80mph half way around the world non-stop. Any of you students like to respond? Or are you content to follow the palaeontologists and just accept everything they throw at you - melodramatic, theatrical or downright contradictory to the laws of physics?
    Phil Parsons

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Lorena,
    I'm not getting any response from your students. Are they just copying chunks of other people's work and not really understanding it? Please don't let them follow Mike Habib into his wonderful world of the light fantastic. Get them to THINK through what they are writing and stand by it rather than rolling over and doing the sycophant in the face of these 'famous' palaeontologists. Remind them of the story of the Emperors New Clothes. Emperor Habib can give them plenty of opportunity!
    Phil Parsons

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Phil Parsons,
    I am one of Prof. Barba's graduate student, and have been working on the Wagner effect post.
    In you first comment, you said we were more interested in this post, but reading what your next comments, I see nothing related to that. I will be happy to discuss about it with you if you let me know your thoughts.
    Best,
    Olivier Mesnard

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Olivier
    Thank you for responding to my posts. My problem in a nutshell is that I am annoyed with Messrs Habib, Witton, Palmer et al for some of the claims they are making concerning the flight capabilities of the larger, Azhdarchid pterosaurs.
    Their claims are simply not sustainable using the laws of physics!

    Why? Well firstly let me surmise that the bulk of palaeontologists focus on land and sea dwelling creatures. They must surely be used to making sweeping statements about the size and weight of Tyrannosaurs or Plesiosaurs without anyone being able to contradict them. Land animals walk and sea creatures swim and that's about it. So sweeping statements on capabilities don't lend themselves to criticism.

    However, if a creature is to fly it faces a considerable hurdle in the form of the laws of aerodynamics. Habib and Co have extrapolated a single arm bone from Quetzalcoatlus Northropii into an almost mystical creature capable of 80mph flight at 15,000ft and cruising 12,000 miles in 8 days non-stop etc etc.

    I mentioned earlier the story of the Emperor's Clothes? Well, Habib and Co make fine Emperors who have clothed themselves in proposals and theories which, if you take a pause and look closely at them, are plainly not scientific and in my view are just risible. Habib has even admitted that his calculations cannot be published 'because he is still working on them'. Talk about a snake-oil salesman. (And you can tell him I said so!)

    Let's look at your paper on the Wagner effect. I put it to you that the Wagner effect can only apply to small, narrow chord wings. It could be argued that the small, bird-sized pterosaurs might be affected by vortex flow, but Q.n apparently had 30ft wings with Re of the order of 10^6 so I think we would be safe keeping to laminar flow formulae, even for flapping fight. Certainly there will be vortices, but not lift-inducing ones - just drag don't you think?.

    As you know, at low airspeed and narrow wing chord, air viscosity is a dominant factor. The bigger the chord and higher the speed, Reynolds numbers become so high that air viscosity becomes insignificant. With Q.n we are not dealing with a bumblebee, dragonfly or even a sparrow. We are dealing with a 12m span (lets say 4m per flapping wing) and with an aspect ratio which appears to give a mean chord of about 1.5m. Re = (air density/viscosity) x airspeed x chord. If the Cretaceous atmosphere was the same as today's, for a 250Kg creature, the minimum velocity for a wing area of about 13m2 would have to be about 20ms so the formula would result in Re=68459x1.5x20. Reynolds would be is 205,3770 or 10^6 plus. Looks like the Wagner effect is a non-starter wouldn't you say?

    Are you interested in more scepticism from me? I'd be delighted if you would join the 'sensible' side of the pterosaur arguments.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Greetings Mr. Parsons. As always, I appreciate your interest in the subject, but I suspect the reason you aren't getting responses from students or other blog posters here is because your attitude is problematic. Disagreement is fine. Making ad hominem attacks and the like, on the other hand, are not. It's also not helpful to spam comment streams with one liners like "Come on Lorena Barba's team. What about some feedback?"

    I don’t particularly care that you disagree with me, Colin, or anyone else. One cannot be a professional scientist while being fearful of disagreement, after all. However, I do care that you practice some basic etiquette on the blog here at pterosaur.net. I would hope it is obvious that personal attacks, for example, do not constitute a reasonable approach to scientific discussion.

    Another reason that you may not be getting many responses is that you self-describe as an aerodynamicist and then make rather critical errors that undermine this label. For example, at high Re numbers flows become less laminar, not more laminar. Similarly, vorticity is required for lift. Any lifting structures is producing a bound vortex, otherwise it wouldn’t be producing lift. Low Re flows will produce additional vorticity that is mostly absent at higher Re ranges, such as leading edge vortices, but your comment that “Certainly there will be vortices, but not lift-inducing ones - just drag don't you think?” suggests a fundamental misunderstanding regarding vorticity. Those are pretty basic mistakes.

    Keep in mind that Colin Palmer, Jim Cunningham, and I are aerodynamicists. So your argument from authority approach rings rather hollow. It is also telling that the results you find so outrageous have not raised eyebrows among lead aerodynamicists at Lockheed Martin or Scaled Composites (just to use two examples).

    I think you will find it difficult to stimulate discussion if you argue that we can’t even measure fossils. That 60 cm estimate you are up in arms over is based on direct measurements. Quetzalcoatlus is known from nearly complete skeletons. The largest specimen (Q. northopi) is known from a wing (not a single bone). Assuming that the proportions of the large animal were similar to the small ones, the shoulder to hip distance would have been about 0.60 meters. Among azhdarchids, the skull length tend to be about 3-4.5 times the shoulder to hip distance. Are those unusual proportions compared to living animals? Yes. But those are the real proportions. You can be incredulous all you want, but it does not change the measurements.

    Your unsupported incredulity about unremarkable numbers doesn’t help. (15,000 feet is not an extreme altitude for a long-range flyer with a flow-through lung system, for example, and even a passing look at the literature shows that quite a few birds hit that altitude during migration). The same goes for your disdain for my launch reconstructions. If you have serious evidence for bipedal launch, then please do share (or better yet, publish it). However, acting as if it is somehow obviously absurd just makes you seem unfamiliar with the basics of animal launch.

    Baiting is also not a good approach to attracting discussion. My previous quantitative work is published, including information on methodology. Ongoing work is not yet published - that’s why it’s called ongoing. Some of that work has been presented at conferences. I refused to share all of the ongoing calculations and measurements in a public blog prior to peer reviewed publication. That shouldn’t be a surprise.

    I’ll be honest and say that I can’t quite figure out why this work angers you so much. Maybe some of my estimates or predictions will turn out to be wrong someday. That is simply part of science. If you have work that suggests different conclusions then by all means publish it! That’s how we build better models. But I really don’t understand why you are so annoyed that some random professor you’ve never met thinks some extinct reptiles flew well.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Greetings Dr Habib,
    Thank you for at last acknowledging that I am here and arguing my position.
    I am not really interested in battling you with scientific or even aerodynamic formulae. That does not get us anywhere. The reason for my scepticism is that you have been making blatant assumptions about the flight of the large Azhdarchids and then extrapolating these claims beyond believeable reason.
    I believe firmly that these creatures could fly - what I cannot understand is HOW. Your extravagant claims concerning their flight capablities just annoys the heck out of me because they are not supported by reason let alone science.
    I have assembled a Witton/Habib flying machine with its 60cm body and its 11m span wing and put it together in a photograph. It is actually a large dog and a hang glider wing which apparently fits your specification for Q.n.

    I will try and put it up here if I can work out how to do it. I'm not sure I can upload photographs on this site. Watch this space.....

    ReplyDelete
  9. Silahkan di kunjungi ya kawan-kawan 100% Memuaskan
    > Hoki anda ada di sini <
    1 USER ID UNTUK SEMUA GAME
    Kami memberi bukti bukan Janji
    Daftar sekarang juga dan dapatkan bonus menarik dari kami :
    - BONUS DEPOSIT NEW MEMBER 100%
    - BONUS DEPOSIT HARIAN 5.000 - 20.000
    - BONUS REFFERAL 2%
    MIN DEPO & WD HANYA Rp.50.000,-
    BCA - MANDIRI - BRI - BNI - DANAMON
    UNTUK INFORMASI SELANJUTNYA BISA HUB KAMI DI :
    LIVECHAT TOGEL118.COM 24 JAM ONLINE
    Pin BBM : D8AF7278
    LINE : togel118
    WHATSAPP : +855 92985834
    Prediksi">http://prediksibwin.com/">Prediksi Bola
    Cerita">http://ceritasemi.com/">Cerita Dewasa
    Cerita">http://ceritasemi.com/">Cerita Semi
    Cerita">http://ayocoli.com/">Cerita Sex
    Prediksi">http://newsprediksi.com/">Prediksi Togel
    Judi Online
    Agen Bola

    ReplyDelete
  10. Siapkan diri anda untuk kemenangan yang berlimpah di SahabatQQ

    Hanya dengan modal minimal deposit 20.000 dapat membuat anda menjadi jutawan loh ^^
    Dengan 8 jenis game yang seru dan sangat mudah di mainkan

    Apalagi yang kalian nantikan , mari join di SahabatQQ
    Link alternatif :

    - sahabat9988,net
    - Duniasakong,com
    - Duniasakong,net
    - Duniasakong,org
    - Duniasakong,info

    ReplyDelete
  11. Situs Taruhan Sabung Ayam AgenS128 di support provider S128 dan juga bisa dimainkan di smartphone

    SABUNG AYAM LIVE STREAMING, saksikan secara langsung dan pasang taruhan Anda.

    Segera bergabung dengan kami di AGENS128 dan raih bonusmu sekarang juga!!

    BONUS BESAR KLIK DISINI
    SABUNG AYAM INDONESIA
    SABUNG AYAM TERBESAR
    SABUNG AYAM TERBAIK
    PROMO BONUS SABUNG AYAM
    JUDI TARUHAN AYAM
    AGEN JUDI TARUHAN BESAR
    SABUNG AYAM S128


    Untuk info selanjutnya, bisa hubungi kami di:
    WEBSITE : https://www.linktr.ee/s128agen
    BBM : D8B84EE1 / AGENS128
    WA : 0852-2255-5128

    Terima kasih .. Salam Agens128 :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. ituPoker - Agen Sakong Online | Bandar66 | Capsa Susun | Bandar Poker | Judi Domino99 | BandarQ | AduQ | Poker Texas Indonesia



    Agen Judi Online Terpercaya dan Terbaik di Indonesia

    Menyediakan berbagai macam permainan Judi Kartu Online Terlengkap



    1 ID untuk 8 Game Permainan yang disediakan oleh Situs ituPoker



    * Domino99

    * AduQ

    * Poker

    * Capsa Susun

    * BandarQ

    * Bandar 66

    * Bandar Poker

    * Sakong



    => Bonus Cashback 0.3% (dibagikan 2x setiap Minggunya)

    => Bonus Refferal 20% (dibagikan setiap Minggunya seumur hidup)

    => Customer Service 24 Jam Nonstop

    => Support 7 Bank Lokal Indonesia (BCA, BNI, BRI, Mandiri, Danamon, Cimb Niaga, Permata Bank)



    * Pusat Bantuan ituPoker



    LINE : itupokerbiz

    WECHAT : itupokerbiz

    WHATSAPP : +855.1769.6238

    ReplyDelete
  13. Jika anda ingin mengetahuinya maka anda bisa mencari informasi mengenai agen judi berkualitas melalui para pemain judi yang sudah mahir dan profesional yang telah banyak bergabung dengan agen judi.
    asikqq
    dewaqq
    sumoqq
    interqq
    pionpoker
    bandar ceme terbaik
    hobiqq
    paito warna
    http://199.30.55.59/sumoqq78/
    data hk

    ReplyDelete
  14. J P S P O K E R adalah situs judi online dan agen judi online terpercaya yang di layanin oleh CS yang sangat ramah dan cepat dalam memproses Depo dan WD member J P S P O K E R dan di J P S P O K E R tersedia permainan Poker Judi Online Seperti Berikut : (Poker, Capsa, DominoQQ, Ceme, Super Teen, Ceme Keliling, Omaha) dan dapatkan promo dari JPSPOKER sebagai berikut:

    - Bonus New Member Rp. 10.000
    - Minimal Deposit / Withdraw Rp. 15,000.-
    - Bonus Refferal 10%
    - Bonus Rollingan Mingguan 0.3% - 0,5%

    Baca Juga Di Tonton Video jav dan Video Semi kami :
    jpspoker,me(pakai titik ya)

    - Pelayanan Dari Customer Service Yang Cantik Tentunya Sopan Dan Ramah, Hanya di jpspoker dan , Online 24/7 Jam
    - Dijamin Tidak Ada Robot Di Dalamnya 1000% Player VS Player
    Kalau Ada Yang Bisa Berikan Lebih Kenapa Harus Cari Yang Lain!!

    Contact Us
    - Livechat : JPSPOKER.LIVE
    - LINE : jpspoker
    - Whatsapp : +82370836863
    - YM : JPSPOKER

    POKER UANG ASLI
    POKER ONLINE TERBAIK
    JUDI POKER INDONESIA
    AGEN POKER TERBAIK
    AGEN POKER TERPERCAYA
    AGEN JUDI POKER
    JPSPOKER
    BANDAR CEME
    GAME OMAHA
    AGEN DOMINO

    ReplyDelete
  15. AYO DAFTARKAN DIRI KALIAN SEKARANG JUGA DI https://bit.ly/2HsgZcG

    www.dewadominokiu . info juga menyediakan bonus yang diantaranya :

    NEW GAME BANDARPOKER
    RASAKAN SENSASI BERMAIN POKER DAN MENJADI BANDAR !!

    - Bonus Referral 10% otomatis langsung ke IDR anda, dan 10% akan dibagikan setiap hari senin
    - Bonus Cashback 0,5%
    - 300% Fair Play
    - NO ROBOT & ADMIN
    - Proses Withdraw & Deposit Tercepat
    - Di layani dengan 5 bank : Mandiri, BCA, BNI, BRI,Danamon
    - Customer Service yang baik, ramah dan cantik tentunya

    Dengan deposit minimal Rp.15.000 Anda sudah dapat bermain 8 game tersebut yang tentunya seru dan asik..

    untuk info contact dan customer service kami, Anda bisa menghubungi kami di :
    LiveChat : Klik Disini
    YM : dewadominoqq@yahoo.com
    Twitter : @dewadominoqq

    Jangan lupa Like Fanpage kami DewaDominoQQ Fanpage

    ReplyDelete
  16. link alternatif adalah salah satu cara untuk membuka situs pelangiqq untuk menyalurkan hobi main hematqq dan cara asik main online di anekaqq dengan sangat asikqq dan menjadi dewaqq dan ratuqq hanya di arenaqq yang di sediakan oleh paito warna hk sumber : paito warna

    ReplyDelete
  17. ICN Group: Situs Judi Online terbaik dan terlengkap dengan permainan Sportbook, Live Casino, Slot Machine. IDN POKER dan IDN LIVE

    Situs Judi Online
    Daftar Situs Judi Online
    Poker Online
    Agen Bola Terpercaya
    Judi Online Terpercaya
    Situs Judi Online Terbaik

    Situs Poker online terbaik yang memiliki permainan Texas Hold'em Ceme, Ceme Keliling, Capsa, Super 10, Omaha

    Poker Online Indonesia
    Poker Online
    Domino
    Ceme Keliling
    Capsa
    Super 10
    Omaha
    Daftar Poker Online
    Agen Poker Terpercaya

    Situs Togel Online terpercaya yang lengkap dengan prediksi yang dapat membantu anda dalam menuju Jackpot

    4D/3D/2D
    Colok Bebas
    Colok Naga
    Colok Jitu
    Tengah Tepi
    Kombinasi
    Dasar
    50-50
    Shio
    Silang Homo
    Kembang Kempis
    24D
    Roulette
    Sicbo
    12D Games
    Head&Tail
    Oglok
    Dice 6
    Red/White
    Billiards
    Poker Dice
    Gong Ball
    Suwit
    Monopoly

    ICNPRODUK
    EpicBigWin

    ReplyDelete
  18. kunjungi website di bawah ini dan daftarkan diri anda
    http://144.91.88.181/
    anekaqq
    arenaqq
    asikqq
    dewaqq
    hematqq
    pelangiqq
    ratuqq
    ID Pro pasti menang 100%

    ReplyDelete
  19. saksikan live draw togel paling cepat di bawah ini
    live draw sydney
    live draw hk
    live draw sgp
    live draw hk 6d
    prediksiwla
    singapore pools
    https://dtogel.com/
    di atas merupakan situs live draw terbaik di indonesia

    ReplyDelete
  20. Lihat prediksi Syair, paito warna, dan hasil result data togel terupdate di sini :
    Syair SGP
    Bocoran SGP
    paito warna china
    paito warna
    hasil result
    hasil data
    semoga dengan website di atas dapat membantu kalian semua.

    ReplyDelete
  21. jika ingin melihat paito warna paling lengkap kalian bisa mengunjungi website di bawah ini
    paito warna hk
    paito warna hk 6d
    paito warna
    paito singapore
    paito sydney
    paito hongkong
    di atas merupakan situs paito warna terlengkap dan terbaik di indonesia

    ReplyDelete
  22. situs di bawah ini ialah situs yang mengumpulkan keluaran angka togel serta paito warna yang fungsinya membantu para pemain togel membuat prediksi angka togel
    pengeluaran togel
    paito warna
    data togel
    togel cambodia
    paitowarna

    ReplyDelete
  23. Class College Education training Beauty teaching university academy lesson teacher master student spa manager skin care learn eyelash extensions tattoo spray

    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet
    daythammynet

    ReplyDelete
  24. Daftar Togel Online dewatogel website agen Judi Togel Online terpercaya. togelrakyat menyediakan pasaran togel resmi Singapore, Hongkong, Sydney, Cambodia, Jakarta , Sing45 toto macau, China Pools, Bullseye, Saigon toto, Pcso.Kualitas dari agen casino online togelrakyat tidak usah diragukan lagi, karena telah dijamin oleh komunitas togel online SGP HK. Bermain di togelrakyat adalah pilihan yang tepat bagi para pecinta judi togel online di Indonesia.juga ada permainan live casino seperti baccarat , rollate , dice atau dadu dan dragon tiger masih banyak lagi anda juga bisa Nonton Anime di Diaboros Anime.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Kingdomtoto situs judi togel yang setiap hari memberikan kemenangan dengan mudah. Kingdomtoto juga cocok sebagai bandar darat alternatif untuk bermain togel online. Untuk melihat hasil result pasaran togel juga bisa disini ya bos.
    Situs yang sama kami refferensikan untuk anda yaitu kinghorsetoto. Situs paito warna terlengkap.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Nonton Film FULL SUBTITLE INDONESIA Nya Klik disini >> LK21,INDOXX1

    ReplyDelete
  27. Nonton Film FULL SUBTITLE INDONESIA Nya Klik disini >> LK21,STUDIOFILM21

    ReplyDelete
  28. Nonton Film BOKEP Lengkap Nya Klik disini ↓↓↓↓↓↓

    VIDEO BOKEP
    BOKEP INDONESIA VIRAL 2020
    BOKEP BARAT TERBARU
    BOKEP THAILAN TER HOT
    BOKEP ASIAN TERLENGKAP
    BOKEP KOREA TERUPDATE
    HENTAI TERBAIK
    BOKEP JEPANG 2020 TERBAIK
    FILM BOKEP TERLENGKAP DAN TERUPDATE


    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Nonton Film FULL SUBTITLE INDONESIA, Download Film Sub Indonesia, Film INDOXXI, Dan Drama Korea Terupdate Nya Klik disini ↓↓↓↓↓↓



    LK21
    STUDIOFILM21
    DRAKOR TERLENGKAP
    INDOXXI
    BIOSKOP KEREN
    FILMAPIK
    INDOXX1
    ANIME TERUPDATE

    Jangan Lupa Klik Link Di Atas Ya Kak ^^

    ReplyDelete
  29. LigaCapsa Situs Domino99 aman Dan Terpercaya, Murni 100% Tanpa Bot Dan Kami Menyediakan 9 Permainan Berbeda

    Bandarkiu

    Poker Online

    Sakong Online

    AduQ

    Bandar Poker

    Bandar66

    Capsa Susun

    DominoQQ

    Perang Baccarat

    BONUS CASHBACK/TURN OVER 0.5%

    BONUS TERBESAR REFERRAL 10% ( UNTUK SEUMUR HIDUP )

    DEPOSIT & WITHDRAW MINIMAL Rp.25.000,-

    DEPOSIT & WITHDRAW TERCEPAT KURANG DARI 2 MENIT

    100% NO ADMIN & NO BOT

    100% PLAYER VS PLAYER

    100% FAIR PLAY

    CUSTOMER SERVICE ONLINE 24 JAM

    Contact Us

    * Line : LigaCapsa
    * Wechat : LigaCapsa13
    * WhatsApp : +855968463343 (+855 bukan 0855) Ikuti seperti yang tertera ya bos.
    * FACEBOOK : https://bit.ly/342vQ4W

    ReplyDelete
  30. KUBET được cộng đồng cá cược đánh giá là nhà cái số 1 Châu Á trong năm 2019 hiện tại. Với nhiều trò chơi hấp dẫn, tỷ lệ cược cực cao, trải nghiệm mượt mà mang tới cơ hội kiếm tiền cho anh em. KUBET.IO là trang web cung cấp link đăng ký, đăng nhập KU BET - KU CASINO chính thức, hướng dẫn hội viên tham gia các trò cá cược trên nhà cái, cũng như cách nạp tiền, rút tiền.



    Từ khóa: #ku, #kubet, #kucasino, #kubetio, #ku777, #ku888, #ku999, #casino, #thienhabet, #kubetcasino



    Mạng xã hội KUBET chính thức:



    https://www.zenysro.cz/blogy/vztahy-a-partnerstvi/kubet-co-th-c-s-uy-tin-b-t-mi-t-i-ku-casino-kubet-io


    https://muckrack.com/kubet

    https://band.us/@kubetku777

    http://scholar.google.com/citations?user=mgWAXIsAAAAJ&hl=vi

    https://www.internship.edu.vn/companies/blogkubet-kubet-ku-casino-kubet-co/


    ReplyDelete
  31. KUBET được cộng đồng cá cược đánh giá là nhà cái số 1 Châu Á trong năm 2019 hiện tại. Với nhiều trò chơi hấp dẫn, tỷ lệ cược cực cao, trải nghiệm mượt mà mang tới cơ hội kiếm tiền cho anh em. KUBET.IO là trang web cung cấp link đăng ký, đăng nhập KU BET - KU CASINO chính thức, hướng dẫn hội viên tham gia các trò cá cược trên nhà cái, cũng như cách nạp tiền, rút tiền.



    Từ khóa: #ku, #kubet, #kucasino, #kubetio, #ku777, #ku888, #ku999, #casino, #thienhabet, #kubetcasino



    Mạng xã hội KUBET chính thức:


    https://infogram.com/dang-ky-kubet-cach-tao-lap-tai-khoan-ku-bet-don-gian-1h8j4xglr0od6mv

    https://trello.com/kubet

    https://block-x.co/dang-ky-kubet/

    https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyPQbqZIZKV60Q7njSmKe3A


    https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/S5X7VBD

    ReplyDelete
  32. Taxitaithanhhung.vn - công ty cung cấp giải pháp chuyển nhà trọn gói tại Hà Nội. Với mong muốn mang đến cho quý khách hàng dịch vụ vận chuyển nhà tại Hà Nội tốt nhất. Đội ngũ nhân viên chuyển nhà trọn gói Thành Hưng chuyên nghiệp, hệ thống xe tải với số lượng lớn, chúng tôi tự tin cam kết mang đến cho quý khách hàng 1 dịch vụ tốt nhất!

    Từ khóa chuyển nhà Hà Nội - công ty cung cấp dịch vụ chuyển nhà Thành Hưng:

    #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhatrongoitaihanoi #donnhathanhhung #donnhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhagiarehanoi #dichvuchuyennhagiarehanoi

    https://issuu.com/hongnhi5315

    https://ello.co/chuyennhatrongoithanhhung

    https://www.flickr.com/photos/186351652@N04/

    https://trello.com/chuyennhatrongoithanhhung

    https://gab.com/chuyennhathanhhung


    ReplyDelete
  33. KuCasino.Email - Đại lý KUBET - KU CASINO chính thức, nhiều ưu đãi. Khuyến mãi cực lớn, tặng 588K cho hội viên đăng ký, nạp tiền lần đầu.


    Xem thêm: #ku, #kucasino, #kubet, #kucasinoemail, #casino

    http://uid.me/kucasinoemail

    https://about.me/kucasinoemail

    https://www.reddit.com/user/kucasinoemail

    https://mastodon.cloud/@kucasinoemail

    https://ko-fi.com/kucasinoemail


    Webste: KuCasino.Email

    ReplyDelete
  34. Chuyennhasgthanhhung.com - dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói Hà Nội - chuyển nhà tại Hà Nội - chuyển nhà trọn gói Thành Hưng. Công ty cung cấp gói giải pháp chuyển nhà số 1 Việt Nam, liên hệ ngay với Thành Hưng để được báo giá nhanh nhất và chính xác nhất.

    Từ khóa chuyển nhà Hà Nội - công ty cung cấp dịch vụ chuyển nhà Thành Hưng:

    #chuyennhasgthanhhung #chuyennhasgthanhhung.com #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhatrongoitaihanoi #donnhathanhhung #donnhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhagiarehanoi #dichvuchuyennhagiarehanoi


    Hệ thống social chuyển nhà Thành Hưng:

    https://www.flickr.com/photos/185015741@N05/

    https://trello.com/vantaithanhhung/activity

    https://gab.com/vantaithanhhung

    https://www.vietnamta.vn/profile-52778

    https://refind.com/vantaithanhhung

    ReplyDelete
  35. Chuyennhasgthanhhung.com - dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói Hà Nội - chuyển nhà tại Hà Nội - chuyển nhà trọn gói Thành Hưng. Công ty cung cấp gói giải pháp chuyển nhà số 1 Việt Nam, liên hệ ngay với Thành Hưng để được báo giá nhanh nhất và chính xác nhất.

    Từ khóa chuyển nhà Hà Nội - công ty cung cấp dịch vụ chuyển nhà Thành Hưng:

    #chuyennhasgthanhhung #chuyennhasgthanhhung.com #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyennhataihanoi #dichvuchuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhatrongoitaihanoi #donnhathanhhung #donnhatrongoihanoi #chuyennhagiarehanoi #dichvuchuyennhagiarehanoi


    Hệ thống social chuyển nhà Thành Hưng:

    https://www.flickr.com/photos/185015741@N05/

    https://trello.com/vantaithanhhung/activity

    https://gab.com/vantaithanhhung

    https://www.vietnamta.vn/profile-52778

    https://refind.com/vantaithanhhung

    ReplyDelete
  36. TOPSoiCau.com - Soi cầu xổ số 3 miền, dự đoán kết quả XSMB, XSMT, XSMN chính xác. Soi cầu bạch thủ, song thủ, lô kép, lô xiên, dàn đề chuẩn tại TOPSoiCau


    Xem thêm: #topsoicau, #soicau, #soicauxsmb, #soicauxsmt, #soicauxsmn, #dudoanxsmb, #dudoanxsmt, #dudoanxsmn, #soicaurongbachkim, #soicauviet, #soicaulotto, #soicaulovip, #soicau3mien, #soicau7777, #soicau247, #soicau555, #soicau366, #soicauwap, #soicau568, #soicau24h, #soicau888, #soicau666, #soicauwin2888, #soicaukubet, #soicaukhongtu


    topsoicau

    topsoicau

    topsoicau

    topsoicau

    topsoicau


    Website: TOPSoiCau.com

    ReplyDelete
  37. TOPSoiCau - Chuyên trang SOI CẦU MB, MT, MN VIP 24h tốt nhất Việt Nam 247 cho anh em tham khảo, lấy số đẹp. Dự đoán kết quả xổ số 3 miền Bắc, Trung, Nam nhanh nhất hàng ngày.

    Xem thêm: #topsoicau, #soicau, #soicauxsmb, #soicauxsmt, #soicauxsmn, #dudoanxsmb, #dudoanxsmt, #dudoanxsmn, #soicaurongbachkim, #soicauviet, #soicaulotto, #soicaulovip, #soicau3mien, #soicau7777, #soicau247, #soicau555, #soicau366, #soicauwap, #soicau568, #soicau24h, #soicau888, #soicau666, #soicauwin2888, #soicaukubet, #soicaukhongtu


    https://twitter.com/topsoicau

    https://dev.to/topsoicau

    https://stocktwits.com/topsoicau

    https://flipboard.com/@topsoicau

    http://www.folkd.com/user/topsoicau



    Website: TOPSoiCau.com

    ReplyDelete
  38. KUBET - KU CASINO - Nhà cái hàng đầu khu vực châu Á. Cá cược Casino Online, lô đề, xóc đĩa, bóng đá, thể thao, game 3D. Nhận ngay ưu đãi lên tơi 558K khi đăng ký tài khoản KUCASINO, nạp tiền lần đầu.


    Xem thêm: #ku, #kubet, #kucasino, #kubetcasino, #soicaumb, #dande, #dudoanxsmb, #dudoanxsmn, #xsmb, #xsmn, #xsmt, #soicaumt, #soicaumn, #ku777, #ku888, #ku999, #thienhabet

    WEBSITE KUBET CHÍNH THỨC: kubet-kucasino.webflow.io

    Các chuyên mục chính tại KUBET

    KU

    Dàn đề

    Dự đoán XSMB

    Dự đoán XSMT

    Dự đoán XSMN

    ReplyDelete
  39. TOPSoiCau - Chuyên trang SOI CẦU MB, MT, MN VIP 24h tốt nhất Việt Nam 247 cho anh em tham khảo, lấy số đẹp. Dự đoán kết quả xổ số 3 miền Bắc, Trung, Nam nhanh nhất hàng ngày.

    Xem thêm: #topsoicau, #soicau, #soicauxsmb, #soicauxsmt, #soicauxsmn, #dudoanxsmb, #dudoanxsmt, #dudoanxsmn, #soicaurongbachkim, #soicauviet, #soicaulotto, #soicaulovip, #soicau3mien, #soicau7777, #soicau247, #soicau555, #soicau366, #soicauwap, #soicau568, #soicau24h, #soicau888, #soicau666, #soicauwin2888, #soicaukubet, #soicaukhongtu


    https://www.domestika.org/en/topsoicaucom

    https://sketchfab.com/topsoicau

    https://stocktwits.com/topsoicau

    https://vimeo.com/topsoicau/about

    https://gab.com/topsoicau



    Website: TOPSoiCau.com


    ReplyDelete
  40. Taxitaithanhhung.vn- công ty cung cấp dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói tại Hải Phòng - chuyển nhà tại Hải Phòng - chuyển nhà Hải Phòng giá rẻ.

    https://medium.com/@vantaitthanhhung/chuyen-nha-tron-goi-hai-phong-taxitaithanhhung-vn-ed41a7a9c6f0

    https://sketchfab.com/chuyennhahaiphong

    https://infogram.com/dich-vu-chuyen-nha-tron-goi-hai-phong-1h7j4d83vp0x6nr?live

    https://stocktwits.com/chuyennhahaiphong

    https://www.domestika.org/en/chuyennhahaiphong

    Từ khóa chuyển nhà:
    #taxitaithanhhung
    #chuyennhahaiphong
    #chuyennhatrongoihaiphong
    #chuyennhataihaiphong
    #chuyennhahaiphonggiare
    #dichvuchuyennhahaiphong
    #vanchuyennhahaiphong
    #chuyennhahanoiuytin
    #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihaiphong

    Website chuyển nhà Thành Hưng: Taxitaithanhhung.vn


    ReplyDelete
  41. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : Chúng tối chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói - Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng tại Hà Nội - Hải Phòng - Quảng Ninh - Đà Nẵng - HCM


    https://twitter.com/taxitaihanoi

    https://gab.com/Taxitiathanhhung

    https://refind.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://trello.com/taxitaithanhhungvn/activity

    http://www.folkd.com/user/taxitaithanhhungvn

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn

    ReplyDelete
  42. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng: Công ty cung cấp dịch vụ : Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói - Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng tại Hà Nội - Hải Phòng - Quảng Ninh - Đà Nẵng - HCM


    https://about.me/taxitaithanhhung/

    https://www.pinterest.com/taxitaithanhhungvn/

    https://sites.google.com/view/taxitaithanhhungvn/

    https://muckrack.com/taxi-tai-thanh-hung

    https://sketchfab.com/taxitaithanhhung

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn

    ReplyDelete
  43. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói - Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng - dịch vụ vận chuyển Bắc Trung Nam.

    https://ko-fi.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://myspace.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://ello.co/taxitaithanhhungvn

    https://www.scoop.it/u/tructia5288-gmail-com

    http://www.myfolio.com/taxitaithanhhungvn

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn

    ReplyDelete
  44. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng: Công ty cung cấp dịch vụ : Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói Hà Nội - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói Hà Nội - Cho thuê kho bãi - Vận chuyển nhà Bắc Trung Nam.


    https://taxitaithanhhungvn863122739.wordpress.com/

    http://chuyennhahanoi300.mystrikingly.com/

    https://taxitaithanhhungvn.weebly.com/

    http://taxitaithanhhungvn.over-blog.com/

    http://chuyennhahanoi300.mystrikingly.com/

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn





    ReplyDelete
  45. So you suspect your harddisk is defective and you will need some support? We are able to unquestionably support you at our company places of work situated in the heart of Sydney CBD.
    Seputar Togel
    Seputar Togel
    Seputar Togel

    ReplyDelete
  46. So you suspect your harddisk is defective and you will need some support? We are able to unquestionably support you at our company places of work situated in the heart of Sydney CBD.
    Seputar Togel
    Seputar Togel
    Seputar Togel

    ReplyDelete
  47. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói - Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng - dịch vụ vận chuyển Bắc Trung Nam.

    https://getpocket.com/@429T1Ae9g7453p4eWXd61b3d9ep5gd81427yc7rd9boeb2R9c9401a19vc5qa30Z

    https://www.instapaper.com/p/taxitaihanoi

    https://www.vingle.net/taxithanhhung

    https://www.deviantart.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://visual.ly/users/taxitaithanhhung/

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn



    ReplyDelete
  48. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói tại Hà Nội - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói Hà Nội- Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng - dịch vụ vận chuyển Bắc Trung Nam.

    https://www.diigo.com/user/taxitaithanhhung

    https://dashburst.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://enetget.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://www.zoimas.com/profile/taxitaithanhhung

    https://devpost.com/taxitaithanhhung

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn


    ReplyDelete
  49. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói - Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng - dịch vụ vận chuyển Bắc Trung Nam.

    http://www.socialbookmarkssite.com/user/taxitaithanhhung

    https://labs.maarch.org/taxitaithanhhung

    https://gitlab.redox-os.org/taxitaithanhhung

    https://oneway.com/taxitaithanhhung

    https://redliberal.com/@taxitaithanhhung

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn



    ReplyDelete
  50. Taxi tải Thành Hưng - Xe tải Thành Hưng - Vận tải Thành Hưng : chuyên cung cấp các Dịch vụ chuyển nhà trọn gói tại Hà Nội - Chuyển văn phòng trọn gói Hà Nội- Cho thuê kho bãi - Dịch vụ cho thuê kho xưởng - dịch vụ vận chuyển Bắc Trung Nam.

    https://www.vietnamta.vn/taxitaithanhhung

    https://gamejolt.com/@taxitaithanhhun

    https://weheartit.com/taxitaithanhhungvn

    https://www.zoimas.com/profile/taxitaithanhhung

    https://sinblr.com/@taxitaithanhhung

    Từ khóa liên quan:
    #taxitaithanhhung #xetaithanhhung #vantaithanhhung #vanchuyenthanhhung #taxithanhhung #taithanhhung #xethanhhung #chuyennhathanhhung #chuyennhatrongoithanhhung #dichvuchuyennhatrongoihanoi #vanchuyennhahanoi #chuyennhahanoiuytin #chuyennhahanoi #chuyennhataihanoi #chuyennhatrongoihanoi #dichvuchuyennhahanoi #dichvuchuyenhathanhhung #chuyennhahanoigiare #chuyen nha #chuyennhatrongoi #chuyenvanphongtrongoi #chuyennhabacnam #vanchuyenbacnam

    Website: Taxitaithanhhung.vn

    ReplyDelete